Does a Crash Report Say Who’s at Fault?

does a crash report say who's at fault

No. A Texas crash report does not state who was at fault. It records what the investigating officer believes happened and what factors may have contributed to the wreck. That opinion can be important evidence in a car accident case, but it does not make the final decision about fault or who must pay. The final decision belongs to the insurance company, the jury, or the judge. Because the report does not settle the question of fault, a car accident attorney can help you build a claim that stands on more than the officer’s initial impression and the other driver’s account. On this page we’ll go into detail on these topics covering:

  • How a Crash Report Is Used in Texas Accident Litigation
  • Why Insurers Look Beyond the Report
  • What If the Crash Report Is Wrong?
  • Questions About Your Crash Report?

How a Crash Report Is Used in Texas Accident Litigation

A crash report can be admitted into evidence in a Texas civil case. Under Texas Rule of Evidence 803(8), a public record or report is admissible if it sets out the office’s activities, matters observed under a legal duty, or factual findings from an authorized investigation. In a civil case, factual findings are admissible unless the opponent shows the sources or circumstances lack trustworthiness. Tex. R. Evid. 803(8)(A)(iii), (B).

The officer’s legal duty to create the report is part of what makes it trustworthy. Texas Transportation Code § 550.062(a) states:

“A law enforcement officer who in the regular course of duty investigates a motor vehicle collision shall make a written report of the collision if the collision resulted in injury to or the death of a person or damage to the property of any one person to the apparent extent of $1,000 or more.”

Subsection (b) requires the report to be filed electronically with the Texas Department of Transportation not later than the 10th day after the collision. That duty is why courts treat the report as a public record rather than a casual statement.

When the Report Is Admissible

Texas courts have applied Rule 803(8) to crash reports. In McRae v. Echols, 8 S.W.3d 797 (Tex. App.—Houston [1st Dist.] 2000, pet. denied), the court held that an accident report was admissible under Rule 803(8) and that the officer’s conclusions based on a factual investigation satisfied the rule’s trustworthiness requirement. That means a report is not automatically kept from the jury just because it contains an officer’s opinion about how the crash happened.

When the Report May Be Excluded or Redacted

But the report is not automatically admissible in full. The opponent bears the burden to show the report lacks trustworthiness. Tex. R. Evid. 803(8)(B). Courts look at the source of the information, whether the officer had a duty to report, and whether the findings are based on a factual investigation. See McRae, 8 S.W.3d at 797.

Officer Testimony

Officer TestimonyThe report itself can be admitted without the officer testifying. The officer may testify as a fact witness about what they observed and did. But an officer is not automatically qualified as an expert just because they investigated the crash.

In Clark v. Cotten, 573 S.W.2d 886, 887 (Tex. Civ. App.—Beaumont 1978, writ ref’d n.r.e.), a state trooper with eight and a half years of service and 350 investigated accidents was not allowed to opine on the cause of the accident.

The court held: “We do not believe this testimony qualified the officer to opine the ultimate cause of this accident — the jury’s prerogative — and overrule this point.” The court also adopted the observation that regular police officers “generally … lack such training and experience as would qualify them to make a scientific analysis from physical evidence, regardless of how many accident scenes one may have examined.” To offer the officer as an expert, the offering party must show the officer has the knowledge, skill, experience, training, or education to give an opinion on the specific issue. Tex. R. Evid. 702.

How the Jury Weighs the Report

If the report is admitted, the jury may see it and consider it along with the other evidence. The report’s weight is up to the jury. A jury can accept the officer’s account, reject it, or give it more or less weight based on video, witness testimony, vehicle data, or expert reconstruction.

The officer’s investigation may flag contributing factors such as:

  • Speeding or driving too fast for conditions
  • Failing to yield
  • Following too closely
  • Making an unsafe lane change
  • Running a red light or stop sign
  • Driving while distracted
  • Driving after drinking
  • Making a faulty turn

Those entries are the officer’s assessment, not a legal ruling. A ticket issued at the scene can also support a fault claim, but neither a ticket nor the officer’s opinion settles the issue on its own.

Texas reduces your recovery if you are found partly at fault, and bars recovery entirely if you are more than 50% at fault. A crash report that pins the contributing factors on the other driver is useful evidence against that argument.

Why Insurers Look Beyond the Report

Why Insurers Look Beyond the ReportAn officer who responds to a crash almost never saw it happen. The report is assembled after the fact from the physical evidence at the scene, the resting positions of the vehicles, and statements from the drivers and any witnesses who remained. That can produce an accurate account, but the officer’s view is limited.

Responding officers generally do not pull phone records, download event data from the vehicles, or subpoena medical records as part of a routine crash investigation. Those tools belong to the parties once a claim or a lawsuit is filed.

That is why an insurance company rarely treats the report as the final word, even when it favors the insurer’s own insured. The adjuster builds a separate file and compares the report against photos and videos from the scene, dashcam or nearby security footage, witness statements, vehicle damage, electronic vehicle data, phone records, medical records, and testimony from crash experts.

Each piece tests a different part of the officer’s account: video shows speed and lane position, damage patterns show which vehicle struck which, vehicle data shows braking and reaction time, phone records show distraction, and experts reconstruct the crash when the physical evidence is unclear or disputed.

None of this means the report is unimportant. It means the report is one piece of a larger record, and the side that builds the fuller record usually wins the fault argument.

What If the Crash Report Is Wrong?

Drivers should request a copy and check every page. Reports can contain a wrong street name, insurance company, vehicle movement, or injury description.

The CR-3 is only the report. It is not the officer’s entire file. The investigating agency may also hold the officer’s field notes, scene photographs, measurements, and in some cases dashcam or bodycam video. Those materials are not part of the report and will not appear in the copy from TxDOT. Requesting the full investigative file, or obtaining it later in discovery, often turns up details the report omits.

A driver may ask the investigating agency to correct a clear factual error. Factual corrections such as a misspelled name, the wrong street, a transposed vehicle, are usually straightforward. Changing an officer’s opinion about what caused the crash is harder, and the agency may refuse.

When new information comes in, the agency may prepare a supplemental report. A supplement adds to the file; it does not erase the original. If the case goes to litigation, both the original report and any supplement are generally discoverable, so a corrected report does not make the first version go away. The other side can still use the original to argue the officer changed their story.

Even if the officer does not change the report, you can still use photos, video, witness information, or other evidence to challenge it.

Questions About Your Crash Report?

If you were injured in a Texas car accident and have questions about how a crash report affects your claim, contact us. We can review the report, identify inaccuracies, and explain how fault is likely to be allocated in your case. Call or use the contact form to schedule a free consultation.

Schedule your FREE Case
Consultation

GET A FREE CONSULTATION 713.522.3000